December 4, 2011
Article Update: December 11, 2011
Resource Version Update: April, 2013 | Release Notes
In a 2004 essay titled, Big IA is Now UX, Peter Boersma asserted that information architecture was a practice among many that contributed to the effort of user experience design. DSIA Research Initiative refers to this claim as the Boersma Assertion. The Boersma assertion implies that the complete practice of user experience design overlaps or entails some aspect of every form of professional practice in the design and development of computing interfaces. However, Boersma’s assertion never included an argument that explained where the overlap of UX design occurs throughout each practice. Since the publication of Big IA is Now UX, no supporting argument had been proposed.
In a November, 2011 column titled, The T-Model and Strategies for Hiring IA Practitioners – Part 2, Nathaniel Davis revealed the overlap of user experience design across multiple practices. In an effort to explain the UX design skills that can be expected from a maturing IA practitioner, Davis needed to modify the grouping of practices found in Boersma’s original proposal. Davis then produced an order grid* that contained the specific areas of interests for each practice vertical, and as a consequence provided evidence of how user experience design overlaps the first three tiers of each practice.
Nathaniel Davis contends his segmentation for UX design practice verticals is the first attempt made by a practitioner within the IA community to validate the Boersma assertion.
More importantly, while the proposed segmentation reveals a great deal about the domain of user experience design and related practices, it ultimately helps to further ground the positioning of the practice of information architecture and its value as a business function within an organization.
- Use for individual skills assessment for IA and UX design professionals - If you're a manager, use this grid as a guide for determining the practice tiers that are most relevant for the UX design position you are trying to fill within your organization. If you're a UX designer, acquiring proficiency in the tiers within the section highlighted "User Experience Design" is imperative. However, you can easily use the chart to know the unique interests of a particular practice such as information architecture.
- Use as a checklist for applying IA and UX design methods - Every project will not need to cover every possible business assumption, and design and development method—just the right ones. To evaluate a project's scope, use this chart as a guide to determine the areas a project may need to consider.
- Use for gap analysis for evaluating IA and UX design methods - If a project has been completed, use each practice tier to evaluate the execution of a UX design project. Consider it as a light heuristics benchmark for UX design activities.
Download UX Design Practice Verticals
Boersma, Peter. "T-model: Big IA is Now UX." November 6, 2004. Retrieved December 2, 2011.
* Communicated as a linear, first-order extraction